Licensed and insured Mobile locksmith in North Park, San Diego · Open 8 am to 9 pm, every day

Troubleshooting

Key Broke Off in the Lock? Here Is What to Do

Stop turning, keep the other half and look at the lock. If part of the key stands out past the face of the lock, you can often pull it straight out with needle-nose pliers. If the break is flush or below the face, stop there. Glue, the other half and more twisting all push it deeper.

By the Cabrillo Locksmith team Updated

First thing to do
Stop turning and let go of the key
Pull it yourself when
Part of the key stands out past the lock face
Never use
Superglue, or the other half of the key
Keep
The broken half, so a new key can be cut from it

Key snapped in the lock? The first five minutes

Stop turning, then work out whether you can reach the piece. In this order:

  1. Let go of the key. Every extra turn pushes the broken piece against the pins and can snap it again.
  2. Keep the other half. Put it somewhere safe. A locksmith can cut a new key from the two halves.
  3. Check the door. If it is locked and you are outside, try the other doors before anything else. If it is unlocked, there is no rush.
  4. Look at the lock face. Is part of the key standing out past the front of the lock, or is the break flush with it or below it? That decides your next step.
  5. If it stands out, try pliers once. See the section below. If it is flush or below, stop and call.

What not to do with a key broken in a lock

Most broken keys that end up costing more were made worse in the first few minutes. Avoid these:

  • No superglue. Once it hardens inside, a five-minute pull can become a lock that has to be stripped or thrown away.
  • Do not push the other half in. It shoves the tip deeper, where it wedges between the pins.
  • Do not keep turning. If the stub moves, it can drag the lock part way round and jam it there.
  • Do not dig with a paperclip, a nail or a screwdriver. These push more often than they pull, and they scratch the keyway.
  • Do not hit or pry the lock. You will damage the door or the lock and the piece will stay put.

How to get a broken key out of a lock with pliers

You can try when part of the key stands out past the lock face, enough to get a grip with needle-nose pliers. If you have a dry lock lubricant, give the keyway a short spray first. Then:

  1. Turn it back if needed. A key only comes out in the position it went in. If the stub has turned, use the pliers to turn it gently back.
  2. Grip it firmly. Use the tips of the pliers on the flat sides of the blade.
  3. Pull straight out. Steady and slow, with no wiggling or twisting.

Stop if the pliers slip twice, if the piece does not move, or if anything you do pushes it further in. One more try can turn a quick extraction into a lock that has to come apart.

When to call a locksmith for a broken key

Call when the break is flush or deep, when the pliers have slipped twice, or when the door is locked and you are outside. Tell us where the key broke, what lock it is and whether you still have the other half. The tools and steps are on our broken key extraction page.

If you are locked out with the key broken in the only door, the same visit can include opening it, as a house lockout. A key that snapped in a car ignition is a call straight away, no pliers. If the ignition was already stiff, read key won’t turn in the ignition too.

Why keys break off in locks

A key snaps when it meets more resistance than the metal can take. The usual causes:

Cause What it looks like
A worn key The blade is thin at the shoulder, or the cuts are rounded off
A stiff lock The key needed force or jiggling for weeks before it broke
A door out of line The lock turns easily with the door open, but not with it shut
The key used as a handle You pull the door shut by the key

When a stiff lock or a door out of line caused the break, the next key will go the same way unless the lock is fixed. That is a job for lock repair.

Broken keys and salt-air locks near the San Diego coast

Near the ocean, a key that snaps has often been fighting a lock that salt air made stiff. Sea spray leaves salt that holds a damp film on the metal, blown sand works into the keyway, and the pins start to drag. Plated zinc locks, common at low prices, corrode first.

If you live in Ocean Beach or another beach neighborhood, treat a stiff key as the warning. Wipe the salt off outside locks with a damp cloth every few weeks, dry them, and use a dry lubricant rather than oil. Once a key has broken in a corroded lock, broken key extraction gets the piece out, and the corroded parts behind it usually need replacing.

How to keep keys from breaking in a lock

Treat the lock and the key, not just the broken piece. Most of this takes a few minutes:

  • Replace keys that are wearing thin. Have new ones cut from the original or to the key code, not from a worn copy. For a car, keep a spare car key cut from a good key, so one snapped blade cannot leave you stranded.
  • Lubricate the lock once a year with a dry PTFE or graphite lubricant, not an oily spray.
  • Fix a lock that is getting stiff before it snaps a key. Our stuck door lock troubleshooting guide shows how to find the cause.
  • Pull the door by the handle, never by the key.
  • Do not force a key that will not turn. Stop, jiggle gently, and check the door is pushed fully shut.

Sources

The laws and official pages behind the facts on this page. Each link opens the original document.

FAQ

Quick answers

Can I use superglue to get a broken key out of a lock?

We advise against it. The idea is to stick a matchstick or the other half to the broken tip, but liquid glue does not stay put. It creeps into the cylinder and hardens around the tiny parts. If that happens, a simple extraction becomes a cylinder that has to be taken apart or replaced.

Can I push the broken piece out from the other side?

No. On most door locks the keyway has no opening at the back, so there is nowhere for the piece to go. Pushing it only drives it further in and wedges it against the pins. A locksmith can take the cylinder out of the door and work on it from the back, but that needs the lock taken apart.

Can the lock still be used after a key breaks in it?

Not until the piece is out. Even if it looks like the lock turns, the broken tip holds the pins in the wrong place and can jam it part way. Once the piece is removed, a lock that worked before usually works again, and a new key is cut from the two halves.

What if the key broke with the door locked and I am outside?

Check every other way in first: the back door, a side door, a garage, or someone with a spare. If there is none, a locksmith can open the door and pull the piece out in the same visit. We check your photo ID before we open any home, as California law requires.

Is a broken key in the car ignition the same job?

Close, but treat the car more gently than a front door. Leave the stub alone and keep pliers away from the ignition, since its wafers bend easily and a new cylinder costs far more than an extraction. Put it in park, set the brake and call. The piece comes out where the car sits.

Keep reading

More guides

  • Troubleshooting

    Keys locked in the car

    What to do the moment you lock your keys in the car: when to call 911, what to check first and when a locksmith is the answer.

  • Troubleshooting

    Locked out of the house

    What to do when you are locked out of your house, in order, what not to try and what a locksmith visit costs.

  • Troubleshooting

    Locked out after 9 pm

    Locked out after 9 pm, when we are closed: when to call 911, free ways back in, and how to vet a night locksmith.

Call or get a quote

Tell us what happened

Call and say what happened. For a car, have the year, make and model ready. You get a range on the phone and the exact price before work starts.

(619) 940-1565

  • Open 8 am to 9 pm, every day
  • Licensed and insured
  • Serving North Park and 31 more San Diego neighborhoods and nearby cities, including La Jolla, Tierrasanta, La Mesa, National City and Coronado

Request a quote

Locked out right now? Call instead. The form is for jobs that can wait until we reply.

Call (619) 940-1565 Get a quote