- First test
- Turn the lock with the door open
- Turns freely open, stiff shut
- The door or strike is out of line
- Lubricant to use
- Dry PTFE spray, or graphite used sparingly
- Lubricant to avoid
- Oily sprays, which hold dirt and grit
Step 1: test a stiff lock with the door open
This one test tells you whether the problem is the lock or the door. Open the door, then lock and unlock it with the key and the thumb turn several times.
- It turns freely with the door open. The lock is fine. The bolt or latch is rubbing on the strike plate when the door is shut. Go to step 2.
- It is stiff with the door open. The problem is inside the lock: the cylinder, the bolt or both. Go to step 3.
- Only the key is stiff, the thumb turn is easy. The cylinder or the key is the problem, not the bolt. Go to steps 3 and 4.
Step 2: fix a lock that only sticks with the door shut
A lock that only sticks with the door shut means the bolt is not entering the strike cleanly. The usual causes:
- Sagging hinges. Loose screws, most often in the top hinge, let the door drop so the bolt hits the bottom of the strike. Tighten every hinge screw first.
- A swollen door. Wood doors take on moisture and grow in damp months, then pinch the frame. If the door rubs the frame as it closes, this is likely.
- A misaligned strike. Look inside the strike opening for scrape marks, bare metal or splintered wood. They show which way the bolt is hitting.
A quick check: push or lift the door while you turn the key. If the lock suddenly turns easily, the alignment is out. Moving or filing the strike plate fixes most of these, but tighten the hinges before you file anything, or you may file the wrong edge.
Step 3: clean and lubricate a stiff lock cylinder
When the lock is stiff with the door open, something inside it is dirty, dry, corroded or worn. Clean and lubricate it first.
| Lubricant | Use it? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Dry PTFE lock spray | Yes, the first choice | Goes on wet, dries to a slick film that does not hold dust |
| Graphite powder | Yes, sparingly | Works well in small amounts. Too much packs the cylinder, and damp air can make it clump |
| Oily sprays and household oil | No | Stay wet and collect dust and grit, so the lock gets worse |
| Grease | No, not in the keyway | Too thick for the pins and holds dirt |
If someone has already put oil in the lock, flush it with a cleaner that leaves no residue and let it dry before you use a dry lubricant. Never put graphite on top of oil, because the two form a paste. One short spray into the keyway is enough. Work the key in and out and turn it a few times.
If the lock is still stiff after a clean and a dry lubricant, the parts are worn or corroded, and lubricant will not bring them back.
How salt air makes door locks stick near the coast
Near the ocean, salt air is often the cause. It carries salt and moisture into the keyway and onto the bolt, and the metal corrodes from the inside. In Ocean Beach, Point Loma, Mission Beach and Pacific Beach, we see stiff cylinders, rusted latch springs and bolts that drag in the door.
Plated and low-grade hardware fails first. A yearly clean and dry lubricant slows the damage. When a lock has corroded through, replace it with one built for salt air. Our guide to the best locks for coastal homes explains which finishes and materials last.
Stiff mortise locks on older San Diego doors
In an older San Diego house, a stiff lock may be a worn mortise lock: a steel case set in a pocket in the door edge. Many homes in Golden Hill, Kensington and Mission Hills keep their original doors. The worn part inside is usually small, a latch spring or a seized cylinder, and it is replaced with the case left on the door. An old mortise lock repaired costs $140 to $340.
Step 4: is the door key worn, or the lock?
Try another key for the same lock. If it turns smoothly, the first key is worn: its cuts have rounded off and it no longer lifts the pins to the right height. Get a new key cut from the original or to the lock’s code, not copied from the worn one.
If every key is stiff, the pins inside the lock are worn. A lock rekey replaces the pins and gives you new keys, which often fixes a worn cylinder for less than a new lock. Do not force a stiff key. That is how keys snap, and then you need broken key extraction as well.
Repair or replace a stiff door lock?
Repair the lock when cleaning, lubricating, adjusting the strike or rekeying brings it back. If you would rather not do it yourself, that is our lock repair service. Replace it when one of these is true:
- The bolt or cylinder is corroded and still stiff after cleaning.
- The bolt is bent, or it no longer throws all the way out.
- The lock is a light, cheap model that has worn through.
- You want a stronger lock or a deadbolt on a door that has none.
For a new deadbolt or a lock fitted to a door that needs it, see lock installation. We give you the price before any work starts. If you rent, ask your landlord before replacing a lock: our guide to California renter lock rules explains who may change one.