Licensed and insured Mobile locksmith in North Park, San Diego · Open 8 am to 9 pm, every day

Guide

Rekey vs Replace Locks: How to Choose

Rekey when your locks work well and the problem is who has keys: it costs $20 to $50 per lock plus a service call. Replace when a lock is worn, damaged or low grade, or when you want a keypad or smart lock. Many homes need both: replace the bad lock and rekey the rest to match.

By the Cabrillo Locksmith team Updated

Rekey
$20 to $50 a lock; service call $50 to $95 per visit
Replace a deadbolt
$100 to $250, lock included
Rekey when
The lock works and you do not know who has keys
Replace when
The lock is worn, broken or you want a new function

Should you rekey or replace your locks?

Rekey if the locks are sound and the problem is who has keys. Replace if the lock itself is the problem: worn, damaged, low grade or the wrong kind of lock for the door.

Rekeying changes the small spring-loaded pins inside the cylinder so they line up for a new key. Every old key stops working the moment the cylinder goes back in. The lock body, the bolt and the trim stay exactly as they were. Replacing takes the whole lock off the door and puts a new one in the same holes.

Rekeying vs replacing a lock, side by side

Rekey Replace
What changes Only the pin stack, and so the key The whole lock: cylinder, bolt, trim
Old keys Stop working Stop working
Cost $20 to $50 each, with one $50 to $95 service call per visit $100 to $250 for a standard deadbolt, $250 to $500 for a high-security one
Whole house, three to five doors $110 to $345 Each lock priced on its own, new hardware included
Right choice when The lock works smoothly and you want old keys dead The lock is worn, damaged, low grade or you want a new function
Time Shortest: the lock stays on the door Longer: each lock comes off, more if the door needs drilling

When rekeying your locks is the right call

Rekey when the hardware is in good shape and you simply do not know where every key is. That covers most of the common reasons people call:

Spare copies for the household are $3 to $8 apiece while we are there. What happens to the cylinder during a rekey is explained on our lock rekey page, and our rekey cost guide shows what the bill is made of.

When replacing a lock is the right call

Replace when rekeying would only put a new key in a lock that is already failing. Signs that a lock should go:

  • It is worn. The key catches, the bolt drags or the knob wobbles on its spindle. Worn parts inside the cylinder do not come back with new pins.
  • It is damaged. A forced door, a drilled cylinder or a bolt bent from being slammed into a misaligned strike.
  • It is low grade. Locks are tested to ANSI/BHMA grades 1, 2 and 3, with grade 1 the toughest. A light-duty lock on a busy front door wears fast.
  • It corrodes. Near the coast, salt air pits the finish and seizes the internals. Our guide to locks for coastal homes covers what holds up.
  • You want a different function. A keypad, a smart lock or a deadbolt on a door that only has a knob. Those are new hardware by definition. See lock installation and smart lock installation.

A lock that is only dirty and stiff, or a bolt that drags because the door has moved rather than because the lock is worn, may need neither. Lock repair cleans, adjusts or realigns it and keeps the lock on the door: a sticking lock cleaned and adjusted runs $70 to $140.

A lock you supply can be fitted for $60 to $130 per lock in labor. Our lock change cost guide covers what new deadbolts and smart locks cost fitted.

Replace one lock, rekey the rest to one key

Most houses do not need all one or all the other. A common visit replaces the one lock that is failing and rekeys the others so a single key opens every door.

The catch is the keyway: the profile of the slot, which has to match the grooves on the key. Two locks can only take one key when their keyways match. When a replacement is chosen to match the keyway of the locks that stay, everything can be keyed alike in one visit. Tell us on the phone how many locks you have and which one is giving trouble, and we will give you a price range for the mix.

Mistakes to avoid when rekeying or replacing locks

  • Replacing good locks just to get new keys. You pay for hardware you did not need.
  • Rekeying a lock that is failing. You pay twice when it wears out next year.
  • Forgetting the back door and the door from the garage. A rekey is only as good as the lock you skipped.
  • Buying a new lock with a different keyway. You end up carrying two keys again.

Every price on this page is on our locksmith prices page, and you get the exact figure before any work starts.

Sources

The laws and official pages behind the facts on this page. Each link opens the original document.

FAQ

Quick answers

Is it cheaper to rekey or replace a lock?

Rekeying is cheaper. Putting three to five house locks on one new key usually totals $110 to $345 with the trip included. Swapping out a single standard deadbolt is $100 to $250 on its own, because you are buying the hardware as well as the labor.

What is the difference between rekeying and changing a lock?

Rekeying keeps the lock on the door and changes the pins inside the cylinder so a new key works and old keys stop working. Changing the lock removes the whole lock and fits a new one. Both lock out old keys. Only replacing changes how the lock looks, feels or works.

Does rekeying make a lock more secure?

It makes the lock secure against old keys, which is usually the point. It does not make a weak lock stronger. A worn or low-grade lock is no harder to pick, bump or force after rekeying. If the lock itself is the weak spot, replace it with a better one.

Can every lock be rekeyed?

Most standard knobs, levers and deadbolts with a pin-tumbler cylinder can be rekeyed. A lock that is badly worn, seized or broken inside is not worth the work. Some cheap locks are hard to take apart without damage, and those are usually better replaced. We tell you which ones on the visit.

Can I get one key for all my doors if the locks are different brands?

Only if the locks share a keyway, which is the shape of the key slot. Locks with the same keyway can be rekeyed to one key. If one lock uses a different keyway, the usual fix is to replace that lock with one that matches the others, then rekey everything together.

Should I rekey or replace locks after moving into a new home?

Rekey, unless a lock is worn or you want a different kind. You do not know how many copies of the old keys exist, and rekeying cancels all of them for less than new hardware. If you planned to fit a keypad lock anyway, do that on the same visit.

Keep reading

More guides

  • Guide

    Rekey cost

    What a rekey bill is made of in San Diego, why each extra lock costs less, what a typical home pays and how to keep the total down.

  • Guide

    Renters and lock changes

    California rental lock law in plain English: what the lease decides, landlord lock duties, lock changes for abuse survivors and illegal lockouts.

  • Guide

    New home rekey

    Why to rekey on the day you get the keys to a new house, and a checklist of every lock, code and remote to change.

Call or get a quote

Tell us what happened

Call and say what happened. For a car, have the year, make and model ready. You get a range on the phone and the exact price before work starts.

(619) 940-1565

  • Open 8 am to 9 pm, every day
  • Licensed and insured
  • Serving North Park and 31 more San Diego neighborhoods and nearby cities, including La Jolla, Tierrasanta, La Mesa, National City and Coronado

Request a quote

Locked out right now? Call instead. The form is for jobs that can wait until we reply.

Call (619) 940-1565 Get a quote