Licensed and insured Mobile locksmith in North Park, San Diego · Open 8 am to 9 pm, every day

Guide

Does Car Insurance Cover Lost or Stolen Car Keys?

Sometimes, and it depends on your policy. Liability and collision do not pay for a lost key. Comprehensive covers theft, so a stolen key may be covered, minus your deductible. A roadside plan may cover a lockout, which is not the same as paying for a new key. Read your declarations page and call your insurer first.

By the Cabrillo Locksmith team Updated

Lost key, standard policy
Liability and collision do not pay for it
Stolen key
Comprehensive may apply, minus the deductible
Roadside plans
Lockout help only if the plan includes it, up to its limit
Before you pay
Call the insurer or plan, and keep an itemized receipt

The short answer on car insurance and lost keys

A lost key is usually on you. A stolen key may be covered, and a lockout often is, but each depends on what you bought and what the policy says.

Most drivers have up to five places to look: the auto policy, a roadside plan, the new-car warranty, a dealer key plan, and a home or renters policy.

This is general information, not insurance advice. Your policy wording decides the answer, and your insurer or agent is the one to confirm it.

Which parts of an auto policy can pay for a car key

Only comprehensive is likely to matter. The California Department of Insurance describes the main coverages like this:

  • Liability pays for injuries to other people and damage to their property. It does nothing for your key.
  • Collision pays for damage from hitting another vehicle or an object. A lost key is not collision damage.
  • Comprehensive pays for damage from causes other than collision, theft among them. That is where a stolen key may fit, if your policy treats it as a theft loss.

Comprehensive carries a deductible, the share of a loss you pay before the insurer does. Set it against what a key costs without cover. We charge $120 to $275 to cut and program a transponder key, and $220 to $550 for a proximity fob. If nothing is left to copy, a further $50 to $200 goes on top. If the deductible is close to that bill, a claim gains you little. The car key replacement cost guide breaks those figures down.

Your declarations page, usually the first page of the policy, lists what you bought, including any key replacement benefit or add-on.

What roadside assistance covers when you lose or lock in your keys

Roadside cover can help with a lockout, but it does not buy you a key. Insurers sell towing and road service as an optional add-on, and the California glossary describes towing cover as paying a specified amount for towing and related labor. Whether a lockout counts, and how much the plan pays, is in its terms.

If you belong to an auto club, or a credit card or new-car package lists roadside benefits, read those terms too. Ask each one what the lockout benefit pays and whether you must use their provider before you pay for a car lockout service. If the keys are only locked in, start with the free steps in our keys locked in the car guide.

Warranties and dealer key plans for lost keys

A new-car warranty will not replace a lost key. The Federal Trade Commission describes an auto warranty as a promise to fix certain defects or malfunctions for a set time after you buy. Loss and theft are not defects.

Dealers also sell optional add-ons and service contracts, some of them key replacement plans. What they pay depends on the contract, so find the paperwork before you pay anyone.

Home and renters insurance when keys are stolen with your bag

A homeowners or renters policy may help when keys go in a burglary or with a stolen bag. The state’s residential guide lists theft among the perils a homeowners policy typically covers, and says a renters policy can cover your belongings in the home you rent.

The guide does not mention keys or locks, so ask your insurer whether the policy would pay for the car key, the house locks or neither. If house keys went with the car key, rekeying the locks makes the old keys useless without new hardware.

Who may pay for a lost car key: a comparison

Source of cover What it may pay for What it usually does not
Liability or collision Nothing for keys Any lost or stolen key
Comprehensive A stolen key, if the policy treats it as theft, minus the deductible A key you simply lost
Key replacement add-on Replacement up to the plan’s limit Anything beyond its terms
Roadside plan, auto club, credit card, carmaker Lockout help, if the plan includes it, up to its limit The price of a new programmed key
New-car warranty A defect in the key or fob Loss or theft
Dealer key plan Whatever the contract lists Anything outside the contract
Homeowners or renters Stolen personal property, minus the deductible Depends on the policy wording

What to check before you pay for a new car key

Do these in order:

  1. Read the declarations page. See whether you carry comprehensive, roadside or a key add-on, and what the deductible is.
  2. Call the insurer or plan first. Ask whether the loss is covered, what the limit is, and whether you must use their provider.
  3. Ask how a claim would count. Find out whether a claim of this size could affect your premium.
  4. Get an itemized receipt. It should show the company name and license number, every part and service, and the total. Our guide on how to check a California locksmith license says what else a receipt should carry.

If the keys were stolen, tell the locksmith. On most cars, programming the new key is also the moment to delete the stolen ones from the car’s list of allowed keys, and after that the engine ignores them. How that works is on our car key replacement page.

The cheapest cover is still a second key. A spare made while one key works costs less than any replacement: see spare car keys.

Sources

The laws and official pages behind the facts on this page. Each link opens the original document.

FAQ

Quick answers

Will my rates go up if I claim for a stolen car key?

Only your insurer can answer that. Each company sets its own rules on how claims count at renewal, and a small claim can still be recorded. Ask before you file: give the agent the rough price of the key and your deductible, and ask whether a claim that size would be noted or change your premium.

Does roadside assistance pay for a locksmith?

Sometimes. Insurers sell towing and road service as an optional add-on that pays a specified amount for towing and related labor, and each plan decides whether a lockout counts and how much it pays. Call the number on your card before you book anyone, ask what the lockout benefit covers, and ask whether you must use the plan's own provider.

Does a new car warranty cover a lost key fob?

No. A manufacturer's warranty is a promise to fix defects for a set time, and losing a fob is not a defect. If a fob stops working on its own while the car is under warranty, that is a different question, and the dealer is the place to ask it.

Does renters insurance cover car keys stolen from my apartment?

It may. The state's residential guide lists theft among the perils a homeowners policy typically covers, and says a renters policy can cover your belongings in the home you rent. It does not single out keys, so whether the policy pays for the key, the car's reprogramming or new house locks comes down to its wording. Ask the insurer first.

Is it worth claiming on insurance for one lost car key?

Often not. Our price for a chip key is $120 to $275 including programming, plus $50 to $200 when no working key is left. If your comprehensive deductible is close to or above that bill, the claim pays little or nothing. Compare the two numbers first, and ask the insurer how a claim would be treated.

What paperwork should I keep for a key replacement claim?

Ask your insurer or plan what it needs, and keep an itemized receipt either way. It should show the company name and license number, each part and service with its price, and the total paid. Keep the work order and, if the keys were stolen, any police report number you were given.

Keep reading

More guides

  • Guide

    Car key replacement cost

    Typical San Diego prices for each type of car key, what losing every key adds and how to compare a locksmith's quote with the dealer's.

  • Guide

    Car key from the VIN

    How a VIN leads to a key code, who may request one, what ID the law asks for, and other ways to get the cuts.

  • Troubleshooting

    Lost car keys, no spare

    A step-by-step checklist for losing your only car key: where to look, what to gather, who to call and how to lock out the missing key.

Call or get a quote

Tell us what happened

Call and say what happened. For a car, have the year, make and model ready. You get a range on the phone and the exact price before work starts.

(619) 940-1565

  • Open 8 am to 9 pm, every day
  • Licensed and insured
  • Serving North Park and 31 more San Diego neighborhoods and nearby cities, including La Jolla, Tierrasanta, La Mesa, National City and Coronado

Request a quote

Locked out right now? Call instead. The form is for jobs that can wait until we reply.

Call (619) 940-1565 Get a quote